Home Building services news Bouygues Wins Legal Battle Over £15bn Schools Construction Framework 

Bouygues Wins Legal Battle Over £15bn Schools Construction Framework 

36
0

Bouygues is challenging its exclusion from the framework after narrowly missing out on the final position in the southern high-value project lot by just 0.13 points.

The contractor finished in 11th place with a score of 74.67, just behind McLaren Construction, which secured the tenth and final position with 74.8 points.

Bouygues alleges that the Department for Education (DfE) unlawfully assessed its tender submission, making scoring errors and treating the company unfairly compared with McLaren.

However, the Government sought to have the legal challenge dismissed, arguing that Bouygues had initiated court proceedings two days beyond the permitted deadline.

In a ruling, Mr Justice Coppel rejected the Government’s argument, allowing the legal case to proceed.

The dispute focused on the 30-day deadline for bringing a procurement challenge under the Procurement Act 2023.

The DfE argued that the deadline expired on Saturday 3 January, while Bouygues submitted its claim electronically on Monday 5 January.

However, the judge ruled that because the deadline fell on a weekend, it was automatically extended to the next working day.

He said: “The Claimant’s claims are not time-barred.”

The judge added that even if Bouygues had missed the deadline, he would have granted an extension because of the unusual legal arguments involved and the disruption caused by the Christmas shutdown.

The underlying challenge concerns several questions in the tender evaluation, including one relating to nature-based solutions. Bouygues received just two marks out of ten for this question, despite an internal expectation of eight.

The court heard that an increase of just one mark in Bouygues’ score on any question, or a reduction of one mark in McLaren’s score, would have been sufficient to reverse their positions, provided all other scores remained unchanged.

Bouygues has also questioned how the tender scores were moderated and raised concerns about alleged weaknesses in the DfE’s record-keeping.

The framework has already been formally signed after Bouygues failed to secure an automatic suspension before the extended standstill period expired.

The judge indicated that even if Bouygues eventually wins its case, financial compensation may be a more realistic remedy than securing a place on the framework.

The court has not yet ruled on whether the DfE acted unlawfully in evaluating the tender submissions.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here